Skip to main content

Unless You Believe, It Won't Make Sense

By WizenedSage (Galen Rose) ~

Recently, I re-read an old article on One of the responses to that article, by a Christian named Bob, caught my eye and started me thinking - always a dangerous thing for Christians, but, of course, we atheists are intellectually fearless. Bob’s major point was that unless we truly believe, god and his works won’t make sense. Here is what he wrote:
“People on this site are railing about how religions make people feel imprisoned and God doesn't answer prayers. But none of you seem to remember that unless you TRULY BELIEVE, God and his works won't make sense. That's the key. So you will always "not get it." You are defeated before you even start. Sad, but it is something that non-believers just can't seem to grasp. And then you judge us without understanding that fundamental concept.”

So, Bob says god and his works won’t make sense to me unless I truly believe what I’ve been told about god. True, I added that part about being told, but let’s face it, that’s how we all learned about this god; someone told us. Thus, Bob concludes that I should not discount that message I was told just because it didn’t make sense. This is a familiar refrain among Christians.

It occurs to me that maybe Bob’s onto something here. Maybe if I just believed in those dozens of Hindu gods and their works, then it would all make sense to me. After all, the Hindus certainly appear to be convinced. I’m betting the Muslims got to the same place with Islam, too, by simply believing what they were told about Allah and his works. Once they believed, it all made sense.

It occurs to me that all cults must function this way. From the outside, Jim Jones’ cult, the Heaven’s Gate cult, the Hare Krishna, Scientology, and the cargo cults all appear ridiculous. But, if you can get over that first hump and get inside, then they all make sense, otherwise none of them would ever have sustained a following.

Now, correct me if I’m wrong here, but it seems to me that, if Bob is correct, then there is really no way to tell a false god or religion from a true one from inside the belief system. Once we believe, he says, then it will all make sense. But, clearly, this works for all religions as they all make sense from the inside, so that has to be the worst possible vantage point to make a judgment on any of them.

Also, just because one’s religion “makes sense” to him, that doesn’t prove it’s true or is based on facts, because the guy in the next religion over finds his religion makes sense to him, too. That a religion, any religion, makes sense to someone proves nothing; they all make sense to someone, or they wouldn’t exist!

Here’s where I disagree with Bob. I think that if a god or religion makes no sense from outside the belief system, that is a genuine, useful clue. Consider for a moment that since, for each of us, Bob included, all gods and religions make no sense unless we are on the inside, then, clearly, the default position for all gods and regions is, “Makes no sense.”

Furthermore, we know that, whatever the religion, everyone on the inside is going to have some very strange, even absurd beliefs. For example, the Hindu really believes that Ganesh (Hindu god with the body of a man and the head of an elephant) makes sense. To the fully-practicing Cherokee, the rain dance makes sense. To the Christian fundamentalist, it makes sense that we should all have to pay for Eve’s mistake. To the committed Catholic, the body of Christ really is in the consecrated cracker. And, the fact that these insiders can’t provide reasonable explanations or hard evidence for those beliefs is another very useful piece of information on which to base a judgment. Frankly, it seems obvious to me that a god or religion can ONLY be rationally judged from the outside.

Has Bob even considered that since (in his view) no religion will make sense until he buys into it, that he would likely be a Hindu if that‘s the religion he had heard about first? Could it be that Bob’s religion was really the result of chance? He argues, after all, “that unless you TRULY BELIEVE, God and his works won't make sense.” So, it follows that Bob didn’t choose his religion because it made sense to him - he is saying that it didn’t make sense to him until he believed it. Obviously, Bob didn’t actually choose a religion, he was led into it. We might even say that the religion chose him.

Now, Bob claims that I will always “not get it,” that I’m defeated before I even start, and that I’m dealing with something I “just can’t seem to grasp.” Well, Bob, I get what you’re saying, I really do, but you’re the one who is missing the obvious. I mean, of course your religion only makes sense from the inside, they all work that way - and only that way. No sale here, Bob, maybe you should go peddle your theory where people are accustomed to believing whatever they’re told, like inside a church, maybe?


Popular posts from this blog


By David Andrew Dugle ~ O ctober. Halloween. It's time to visit the haunted house I used to live in. When I was five my dad was able to build a big modern house. Moving in before it was complete, my younger brother and I were sleeping in a large unfinished area directly under the living room. It should have been too new to be a haunted house, but now and then I would wake up in the tiny, dark hours and see the blurry image of a face, or at least what I took to be a face, glowing, faintly yellow, high up on the wall near the ceiling. I'm not kidding! Most nights it didn’t appear at all. But when it did show itself, at first I thought it was a ghost and it scared me like nothing else I’d ever seen. But the face never did anything; unmoving, it just stayed in that one spot. Turning on the lights would make it disappear, making my fears difficult to explain, so I never told anyone. My Sunday School teachers had always told me to be good because God was just behind m

The Blame Game or Shit Happens

By Webmdave ~ A relative suffering from Type 1 diabetes was recently hospitalized for an emergency amputation. The physicians hoped to halt the spread of septic gangrene seeping from an incurable foot wound. Naturally, family and friends were very concerned. His wife was especially concerned. She bemoaned, “I just don’t want this (the advanced sepsis and the resultant amputation) to be my fault.” It may be that this couple didn’t fully comprehend the seriousness of the situation. It may be that their choice of treatment was less than ideal. Perhaps their home diabetes maintenance was inconsistent. Some Christians I know might say the culprit was a lack of spiritual faith. Others would credit it all to God’s mysterious will. Surely there is someone or something to blame. Someone to whom to ascribe credit. Isn’t there? A few days after the operation, I was talking to a man who had family members who had suffered similar diabetic experiences. Some of those also suffered ea

Reasons for my disbelief

By Rebekah ~ T here are many layers to the reasons for my disbelief, most of which I haven't even touched on here... When I think of Evangelical Christianity, two concepts come to mind: intense psychological traps, and the danger of glossing over and missing a true appreciation for the one life we know that we have. I am actually agnostic when it comes to a being who set creation in motion and remains separated from us in a different realm. If there is a deistic God, then he/she doesn't particularly care if I believe in them, so I won't force belief and instead I will focus on this one life that I know I have, with the people I can see and feel. But I do have a lot of experience with the ideas of God put forth by Evangelical Christianity, and am confident it isn't true. If it's the case god has indeed created both a physical and a heavenly spiritual realm, then why did God even need to create a physical realm? If the point of its existence is to evolve to pas

Are You an Atheist Success Story?

By Avangelism Project ~ F acts don’t spread. Stories do. It’s how (good) marketing works, it’s how elections (unfortunately) are won and lost, and it’s how (all) religion spreads. Proselytization isn’t accomplished with better arguments. It’s accomplished with better stories and it’s time we atheists catch up. It’s not like atheists don’t love a good story. Head over to the atheist reddit and take a look if you don’t believe me. We’re all over stories painting religion in a bad light. Nothing wrong with that, but we ignore the value of a story or a testimonial when we’re dealing with Christians. We can’t be so proud to argue the semantics of whether atheism is a belief or deconversion is actually proselytization. When we become more interested in defining our terms than in affecting people, we’ve relegated ourselves to irrelevance preferring to be smug in our minority, but semantically correct, nonbelief. Results Determine Reality The thing is when we opt to bury our

Christian TV presenter reads out Star Wars plot as story of salvation

An email prankster tricked the host of a Christian TV show into reading out the plots of The Fresh Prince of Bel Air and Star Wars in the belief they were stories of personal salvation. The unsuspecting host read out most of the opening rap to The Fresh Prince, a 1990s US sitcom starring Will Smith , apparently unaware that it was not a genuine testimony of faith. The prankster had slightly adapted the lyrics but the references to a misspent youth playing basketball in West Philadelphia would have been instantly familiar to most viewers. The lines read out by the DJ included: "One day a couple of guys who were up to no good starting making trouble in my living area. I ended up getting into a fight, which terrified my mother." The presenter on Genesis TV , a British Christian channel, eventually realised that he was being pranked and cut the story short – only to move on to another spoof email based on the plot of the Star Wars films. It began: &quo

Why I left the Canadian Reformed Church

By Chuck Eelhart ~ I was born into a believing family. The denomination is called Canadian Reformed Church . It is a Dutch Calvinistic Christian Church. My parents were Dutch immigrants to Canada in 1951. They had come from two slightly differing factions of the same Reformed faith in the Netherlands . Arriving unmarried in Canada they joined the slightly more conservative of the factions. It was a small group at first. Being far from Holland and strangers in a new country these young families found a strong bonding point in their church. Deutsch: Heidelberger Katechismus, Druck 1563 (Photo credit: Wikipedia ) I was born in 1955 the third of eventually 9 children. We lived in a small southern Ontario farming community of Fergus. Being young conservative and industrious the community of immigrants prospered. While they did mix and work in the community almost all of the social bonding was within the church group. Being of the first generation born here we had a foot in two