Skip to main content

The Source of Morality

By WizenedSage (Galen Rose) ~

One of the most common defenses of god belief involves the claim that a god is necessary to explain man’s innate morality. Personally, I think this is just another case of people getting carried away with their feelings and not testing a theory rigorously. We need to ask - what does history tell us about man’s innate morality, and what does the Bible tell us about “god’s morality?”

About a year ago, Leah Libresco, an atheist blogger on the Patheos Atheist Portal, announced that she had decided there really was a god and that she was in the process of becoming a Roman Catholic. Now Leah is no dummy; she is a Yale graduate and an obviously smart and articulate writer, so what was at the root of her conversion?

If you doubt that she was a committed atheist to begin with, then you are not alone. As this article, by another atheist blogger shows, there are abundant signs that she was already leaning toward god belief and Catholicism when she started her blog:

In that fateful article where she announces that she has converted to Christianity, she makes it clear that the overriding cause of her transformation involved the question of morals. Speaking of her friends with whom she had debated, she wrote: “I could see where they were coming from, but I stayed put. I was ready to admit that there were parts of Christianity and Catholicism that seemed like a pretty good match for the bits of my moral system that I was most sure of, while meanwhile my own philosophy was pretty kludged together and not particularly satisfactory.”

She describes her startling epiphany thus:

“My friend pressed me to stop beating up on other people’s explanations and offer one of my own.

“I don’t know,” I said. ”I’ve got bupkis.”

“Your best guess.”

“I haven’t got one.”

“You must have some idea.”

“I don’t know. I’ve got nothing. I guess Morality just loves me or something.”


“Ok, ok, yes, I heard what I just said. Give me a second and let me decide if I believe it.”

It turns out I did.

I believed that the Moral Law wasn’t just a Platonic truth, abstract and distant. It turns out I actually believed it was some kind of Person, as well as Truth. And there was one religion that seemed like the most promising way to reach back to that living Truth.”

Apparently, she decided that god IS morality, or, at the least, is the ultimate source of morality. I would argue that she missed the obvious as she she didn’t seek the counsel of history, nor did she examine closely the testimony of the foundational document of her new religion – the Bible - against her new theory.

Libresco claimed that those who explained human morality in terms of evolutionary psychology, “Usually . . . radically misunderstand a) evolution b) moral philosophy or c) both.” Either those who attempted those explanations were complete dunderheads, or she wasn’t really listening, since the need for development of morality in the evolution of intelligent, social animals is a no-brainer. Man is weak against nature and the larger predators when alone. He has no fur against the elements, is, on average, a mediocre problem solver on his own, and is – compared to lions, tigers, etc. – weak and slow. Only by living in groups can he survive and compete successfully, and those groups (tribes, nations, whatever) would not hold together if man acted totally selfishly and had no sympathy for his neighbors. Could anything be more obvious?

Thus, a moral tendency, i.e., a sympathy for others, is indeed innate in man. Yet, history shows that that tendency exists with a very wide range of expression. As the Bible clearly illustrates, what passed for moral behavior was considerably different in Biblical times. The Bible portrays slavery, racism, arranged marriages, gay-bashing, absolute authority of men over women, and women as property as perfectly standard morality. Today, we in the developed world find such a “morality” abhorrent and our laws reflect that fact.

Now, if our morality came directly from god, how is it that what we call moral has changed so drastically over the past 2,000 years?

What passed for moral behavior was considerably different in Biblical times. Further, if our morality is god-given, then why do we disagree on so many moral questions like abortion, gay marriage, premarital sex, capital punishment, etc.? And how does one explain sociopaths, those born without conscience, without sympathy? Where is god in this? Also, there is a vast literature on people whose moral outlooks were totally shifted because of brain damage, tumors, or other disease.

In short, while the normal man or woman does have an innate sympathy for others, the expression of that tendency has changed dramatically over time, and exhibits considerable variance across individuals and cultures. If man got his moral sense from a god, then man has dramatically improved on god’s original plan. Who among us would willingly return to the moral landscape of the Western world of the early 20th century, when women did not have the vote or other equal rights, racism was rampant, and gays stayed in the closet for fear of ridicule or physical harm?

I suggest that Leah Libresco turned to Christianity and Catholicism from purely emotional drives, not from clear-headed consideration of human morality from the facts of human existence and human history. Now, emotion can be good, but when judging how the world really works, the value of hard evidence and logic should never be ignored. The evidence of a god as the basis of human morality adds up to something between scant and none. In fact, I find the evidence overwhelming that nature, through evolution, planted the seeds of human morality, and from there (as Pogo might have put it),
“We have met the morals-maker and he is us.”


Popular posts from this blog


By David Andrew Dugle ~ O ctober. Halloween. It's time to visit the haunted house I used to live in. When I was five my dad was able to build a big modern house. Moving in before it was complete, my younger brother and I were sleeping in a large unfinished area directly under the living room. It should have been too new to be a haunted house, but now and then I would wake up in the tiny, dark hours and see the blurry image of a face, or at least what I took to be a face, glowing, faintly yellow, high up on the wall near the ceiling. I'm not kidding! Most nights it didn’t appear at all. But when it did show itself, at first I thought it was a ghost and it scared me like nothing else I’d ever seen. But the face never did anything; unmoving, it just stayed in that one spot. Turning on the lights would make it disappear, making my fears difficult to explain, so I never told anyone. My Sunday School teachers had always told me to be good because God was just behind m

Reasons for my disbelief

By Rebekah ~ T here are many layers to the reasons for my disbelief, most of which I haven't even touched on here... When I think of Evangelical Christianity, two concepts come to mind: intense psychological traps, and the danger of glossing over and missing a true appreciation for the one life we know that we have. I am actually agnostic when it comes to a being who set creation in motion and remains separated from us in a different realm. If there is a deistic God, then he/she doesn't particularly care if I believe in them, so I won't force belief and instead I will focus on this one life that I know I have, with the people I can see and feel. But I do have a lot of experience with the ideas of God put forth by Evangelical Christianity, and am confident it isn't true. If it's the case god has indeed created both a physical and a heavenly spiritual realm, then why did God even need to create a physical realm? If the point of its existence is to evolve to pas

The Blame Game or Shit Happens

By Webmdave ~ A relative suffering from Type 1 diabetes was recently hospitalized for an emergency amputation. The physicians hoped to halt the spread of septic gangrene seeping from an incurable foot wound. Naturally, family and friends were very concerned. His wife was especially concerned. She bemoaned, “I just don’t want this (the advanced sepsis and the resultant amputation) to be my fault.” It may be that this couple didn’t fully comprehend the seriousness of the situation. It may be that their choice of treatment was less than ideal. Perhaps their home diabetes maintenance was inconsistent. Some Christians I know might say the culprit was a lack of spiritual faith. Others would credit it all to God’s mysterious will. Surely there is someone or something to blame. Someone to whom to ascribe credit. Isn’t there? A few days after the operation, I was talking to a man who had family members who had suffered similar diabetic experiences. Some of those also suffered ea

Are You an Atheist Success Story?

By Avangelism Project ~ F acts don’t spread. Stories do. It’s how (good) marketing works, it’s how elections (unfortunately) are won and lost, and it’s how (all) religion spreads. Proselytization isn’t accomplished with better arguments. It’s accomplished with better stories and it’s time we atheists catch up. It’s not like atheists don’t love a good story. Head over to the atheist reddit and take a look if you don’t believe me. We’re all over stories painting religion in a bad light. Nothing wrong with that, but we ignore the value of a story or a testimonial when we’re dealing with Christians. We can’t be so proud to argue the semantics of whether atheism is a belief or deconversion is actually proselytization. When we become more interested in defining our terms than in affecting people, we’ve relegated ourselves to irrelevance preferring to be smug in our minority, but semantically correct, nonbelief. Results Determine Reality The thing is when we opt to bury our

Christian TV presenter reads out Star Wars plot as story of salvation

An email prankster tricked the host of a Christian TV show into reading out the plots of The Fresh Prince of Bel Air and Star Wars in the belief they were stories of personal salvation. The unsuspecting host read out most of the opening rap to The Fresh Prince, a 1990s US sitcom starring Will Smith , apparently unaware that it was not a genuine testimony of faith. The prankster had slightly adapted the lyrics but the references to a misspent youth playing basketball in West Philadelphia would have been instantly familiar to most viewers. The lines read out by the DJ included: "One day a couple of guys who were up to no good starting making trouble in my living area. I ended up getting into a fight, which terrified my mother." The presenter on Genesis TV , a British Christian channel, eventually realised that he was being pranked and cut the story short – only to move on to another spoof email based on the plot of the Star Wars films. It began: &quo

Why I left the Canadian Reformed Church

By Chuck Eelhart ~ I was born into a believing family. The denomination is called Canadian Reformed Church . It is a Dutch Calvinistic Christian Church. My parents were Dutch immigrants to Canada in 1951. They had come from two slightly differing factions of the same Reformed faith in the Netherlands . Arriving unmarried in Canada they joined the slightly more conservative of the factions. It was a small group at first. Being far from Holland and strangers in a new country these young families found a strong bonding point in their church. Deutsch: Heidelberger Katechismus, Druck 1563 (Photo credit: Wikipedia ) I was born in 1955 the third of eventually 9 children. We lived in a small southern Ontario farming community of Fergus. Being young conservative and industrious the community of immigrants prospered. While they did mix and work in the community almost all of the social bonding was within the church group. Being of the first generation born here we had a foot in two